Exercise: American put-call parity bounds
For American options on a non-dividend-paying stock, put-call parity becomes an inequality (not equality):
Tasks
-
Upper bound. Prove the upper bound by comparing with European equivalents and using the fact that an American option is worth at least as much as the corresponding European.
-
Lower bound. Prove the lower bound by a direct arbitrage argument: if , buy the call, short the stock, invest cash at rate — show this is riskless.
-
Call never exercised early (no dividends). Argue using the bounds or directly that for a non-dividend-paying stock, early exercise of an American call is never optimal, so .
-
American put exercised early. Give a numerical example where : specifically, for a deeply in-the-money put, compare the exercise value with the hold value. For , , , , : verify numerically that (exercise now) while .
-
With dividends. The American-call-never-exercised-early result fails when the stock pays dividends. Why?
Hint
For part 3, combine the bound with (option value non-negative) and to show the exercise value is dominated by the hold value.